AI grading tools for teachers: Which ones handle IB mark schemes

Smiling teacher holding a tablet in a classroom with students

Intro

It's Sunday night. You have 94 scripts to mark, a mark scheme you can't change, and reports due on Friday. So you look for an AI tool to help. But nearly every page you find is written by a company selling one of the tools it reviews.

We looked at four AI grading tools for teachers with one question in mind. Can it mark against an IB markband, an MYP criterion or a Cambridge mark scheme the way you would?

The best AI grading tool depends on what you mark. If you mark essays against your own mark scheme, a standalone essay grader is usually enough. If you run mocks across a whole school against IB or Cambridge mark schemes, you need an assessment platform.

One of the four is AssessPrep, which is ours. We've held it to the same standard as the others, and that includes saying what it can't do.

TL;DR. AI grading tools for teachers

Key takeaway

What it means for your school

All four tools let you use your own mark scheme

That part is easy. The real difference is how closely they follow it

None of them marks each strand inside an MYP level

You get one score per criterion, but not the detail behind it

Some tools turn MYP levels into percentages

A 5 out of 8 is not 62.5%, so the result gives the wrong picture

Point-marked papers and essays need different tools

Very few tools do both well

How we checked these AI grading tools

We didn't mark real scripts with these tools. We read each tool's own help pages and compared them with what an IB or Cambridge mark scheme needs. We read them on 18 September 2026 and checked the main claims again on 5 October 2026, because help pages change often.

The 4 AI grading tools at a glance

Tool

Built for

Marks best

Your own mark scheme?

Handwriting?

One trade-off

Generic AI (ChatGPT, Claude)

Anything you paste in

One-off written answers

Yes, pasted in each time

Yes, from photos

Marks can drift from one script to the next

Gradescope

Universities (used at 2,600+)

Papers with a mark for each correct point

Yes, but every line needs a number

Single-line answers only

Hard to use with worded markbands

CoGrader

Classroom essays

Long written answers

Yes, uploaded as a PDF, DOC or image

Yes

Can't read diagrams, graphs or tables

AssessPrep (ours)

Whole-school assessment

Mocks and internal assessment

Yes, with IB and Cambridge frameworks built in

Yes

Too much for one teacher with 30 essays

Every tool here lets you bring your own mark scheme. The difference is how closely each one follows it.

The 4 AI grading tools, up close

1. Generic AI (ChatGPT and Claude)

This is where most teachers start. You paste in the mark scheme and a student's answer, then ask for a mark and some feedback. It's quick, it reads any mark scheme, and it can even read a photo of handwritten work.

Chat Gpt UI

The trouble starts with a whole class. There's no class list, no batch upload and no record of what it marked. It also doesn't hold on to your standard, so script 40 can be marked more harshly than script 4.

Who it suits: a teacher trying AI marking for the first time on ten scripts.

2. Gradescope

Gradescope is owned by Turnitin and is used at 2,600+ universities. It was built for university problem sets and exam papers. You upload a blank copy of the paper, draw a box around each question, and scan in the scripts. Then you mark one question at a time across the whole class.

Gradescope UI

Its AI sorts similar answers into groups so you can mark a group in one go. The AI never gives the mark itself. A teacher always does.

It works best on papers that give a mark for each correct point, like university maths and science problem sets. Worded markbands are harder, because every line of the mark scheme needs a number. Handwriting reading only works on single-line answers.

Who it suits: a university course with point-marked problem sets. It's built for universities, not schools.

3. CoGrader

CoGrader is a strong choice for essays. It pulls in work from Google Classroom, Canvas, Schoology or Brightspace, or from a scan. You upload your mark scheme as a PDF, DOC or image, and it turns it into a grid. Each student gets a score per criterion, plus strengths and next steps, and nothing goes out until you approve it.

CoGrader

Its ready-made library is mostly US state tests and AP exams, so IB schools upload their own mark scheme. It also can't read diagrams, graphs or charts, which rules out a lot of science, maths and geography.

Who it suits: a humanities department marking long written answers.

4. AssessPrep (ours)

AssessPrep is a whole-school digital assessment platform, used by 800+ schools across 85+ countries. Teachers set the paper, students sit it on screen, and marking happens in the same place.

Import from PDF by AssessPrep

The AI marks multiple choice, short answers, essays and scanned handwriting. IB markbands, MYP criteria and Cambridge IGCSE mark schemes are built in. With seed grading, you mark one answer yourself and the AI follows your standard for the rest of the class. Every AI mark stays a suggestion until a teacher confirms it.

For DP and MYP coordinators, AssessPrep is a digital assessment platform with IB and Cambridge mark schemes built in. So every department marks its mocks the same way.

It isn't right for everyone. It's too much for one teacher with 30 essays, and it takes some setting up. A full year group sitting a mock at once needs good devices and a steady network. And like the others, it gives one score per criterion, not one per strand.

Shannon Johnson, IB MYP Coordinator and DP History Teacher at Fairgreen International School in the UAE, on using AssessPrep's AI feedback:

"We have a policy… 'what went well, even better if'… I can use the AI feature to produce it in this format… and it's cut down on time."

Who it suits: a DP or MYP coordinator running mocks across departments.

Which AI grading tool should you use?

  • One teacher marking typed essays: use CoGrader. EssayGrader and MagicSchool AI do a similar job.

  • A university course with point-marked problem sets: use Gradescope.

  • IB or Cambridge mocks across a department or a whole school: you need a platform like AssessPrep, so every teacher marks against the same framework.

Our guide to grading with AI covers the step-by-step side.

Where AssessPrep fits. IB DP, IB MYP, Cambridge IGCSE and A-Level, or Pearson Edexcel schools that want secure mocks, criterion marking and analytics in one place. It suits the DP or MYP coordinator who owns the exam calendar.

Where it doesn't fit. One teacher with 30 essays. A school looking for a free quiz tool. A school whose devices or network can't handle a full year group at once.

Match the tool to how your mark scheme works, not to the length of its feature list.

Frequently asked questions

Which AI grading tool follows my own mark scheme?

All four tools let you use your own mark scheme. The difference is how closely they follow it. CoGrader keeps worded levels well. Gradescope needs a number on every line, so worded markbands are harder. ChatGPT and Claude read anything you paste in, but they don't keep your standard steady from one script to the next. AssessPrep lets you build your own mark scheme from scratch. Or you can start from the IB and Cambridge ones already built in and change them to suit your task.

Are AI grading tools reliable enough for mock exams?

They can be, as long as a teacher stays in the loop. AssessPrep's AI grading is 85 to 90% accurate, and every mark stays a suggestion until a teacher checks and confirms it. Gradescope and CoGrader also keep AI marks as drafts until a teacher approves them. ChatGPT and Claude keep no record of what they marked, so they're harder to trust for a mock.

Can AI grading tools mark handwritten work?

Yes. Gradescope reads single-line handwritten answers. CoGrader takes a scanned PDF and splits it by student. AssessPrep marks scanned handwriting directly, and ChatGPT and Claude can read photos. Test a few of your own scripts before you rely on any of them for a mock.

Which AI grading tool is best for IB and Cambridge schools?

It depends on who's marking. One teacher with typed essays will do well with CoGrader. Gradescope is built for universities rather than schools. A coordinator running mocks across departments needs a platform. AssessPrep, used by 800+ schools across 85+ countries, has IB and Cambridge mark schemes built in for that job.

Sidhi Baweja

Marketing Lead